|
Cellular forums Home > Archive > GPS > January 2007 > basemap detail
You are viewing an archived Text-only version of the thread.
To view this thread in it's original format and/or if you want to reply to
this thread please [click here]
|
|
| Craig 2007-01-20, 10:33 pm |
| Hello,
I'm shopping for my first GPS and have pretty much narrowed it down to
the Garmin Etrex Legend and the Magellan Explorist 210. Also under
consideration (if I can get a good deal on a used one) are the Garmin Etrex
Legend C and the Magellan Explorist 500LE. How do the basemaps in these
models compare? From what I've researched, these are the pros and cons of
each unit:
Legend: Basemap has more detail than other units (am I correct on this?)
but limited memory and slow
transfers.
Explorist 210: More memory & USB transfers, but basemap has less detail
than the Legend (again, not sure about this point).
Legend C: Color display, autorouting and fast processor, but basemap has
less detail than the B&W legend.
Explorist 500: Color display and potential for autorouting, but basemap is
less detailed (?) and autorouting requires additional software.
What I intend to use these units for:
FUN = charting our course while cruising, checking air speed and altiude
while flying as well as determining what we are flying over, sunrise and
sunset (as well as moon) position and times, finding new areas to fish.
PRACTICAL = finding items of note near interstate exits (gas, food, lodging,
etc.), finding restuarants and other items of interest while traveling (not
necessarily at the exits...realize I will likely need to load maps on all
units to get this info, but which ones offer the most of this detail on the
base maps?), getting directions to these POI, depth of lakes that I might be
boating on, etc.
As mentioned, this will be my first GPS so I would like one that is easy to
use and inexpensive. Autorouting is nice, but not critical as my next car
will likely have a GPS factory installed in it anyway. Finding POI in a
strange are is more important to me. Give me the address and a map and I
can chart my own path.
Craig
| |
| Brad Powers 2007-01-20, 10:33 pm |
| I have the Garmin eTrex Legend, the Vista CSx and the GPSMAP 60CSx;
ironically the basemap in the Legend has more detail than the other two. I
know this for only my area around Western Massachusetts but I presume it's
true of the rest of the US.
Brad Powers
"Craig" <caheaton@netzero.net> wrote in message
news:5ab26$45b28fbf$
4831d176$25044@FUSE.NET...
> Hello,
> I'm shopping for my first GPS and have pretty much narrowed it down to
> the Garmin Etrex Legend and the Magellan Explorist 210. Also under
> consideration (if I can get a good deal on a used one) are the Garmin
> Etrex Legend C and the Magellan Explorist 500LE. How do the basemaps in
> these models compare? From what I've researched, these are the pros and
> cons of each unit:
>
> Legend: Basemap has more detail than other units (am I correct on this?)
> but limited memory and slow
> transfers.
> Explorist 210: More memory & USB transfers, but basemap has less detail
> than the Legend (again, not sure about this point).
> Legend C: Color display, autorouting and fast processor, but basemap has
> less detail than the B&W legend.
> Explorist 500: Color display and potential for autorouting, but basemap
> is less detailed (?) and autorouting requires additional software.
>
> What I intend to use these units for:
> FUN = charting our course while cruising, checking air speed and altiude
> while flying as well as determining what we are flying over, sunrise and
> sunset (as well as moon) position and times, finding new areas to fish.
> PRACTICAL = finding items of note near interstate exits (gas, food,
> lodging, etc.), finding restuarants and other items of interest while
> traveling (not necessarily at the exits...realize I will likely need to
> load maps on all units to get this info, but which ones offer the most of
> this detail on the base maps?), getting directions to these POI, depth of
> lakes that I might be boating on, etc.
>
> As mentioned, this will be my first GPS so I would like one that is easy
> to use and inexpensive. Autorouting is nice, but not critical as my next
> car will likely have a GPS factory installed in it anyway. Finding POI in
> a strange are is more important to me. Give me the address and a map and
> I can chart my own path.
>
> Craig
>
>
| |
| DJ Daimon 2007-01-20, 10:33 pm |
| Craig wrote:
> Hello,
> I'm shopping for my first GPS and have pretty much narrowed it down to
> the Garmin Etrex Legend and the Magellan Explorist 210. Also under
> consideration (if I can get a good deal on a used one) are the Garmin Etrex
> Legend C and the Magellan Explorist 500LE. How do the basemaps in these
> models compare? From what I've researched, these are the pros and cons of
> each unit:
>
> Legend: Basemap has more detail than other units (am I correct on this?)
> but limited memory and slow
> transfers.
> Explorist 210: More memory & USB transfers, but basemap has less detail
> than the Legend (again, not sure about this point).
> Legend C: Color display, autorouting and fast processor, but basemap has
> less detail than the B&W legend.
> Explorist 500: Color display and potential for autorouting, but basemap is
> less detailed (?) and autorouting requires additional software.
>
> What I intend to use these units for:
> FUN = charting our course while cruising, checking air speed and altiude
> while flying as well as determining what we are flying over, sunrise and
> sunset (as well as moon) position and times, finding new areas to fish.
> PRACTICAL = finding items of note near interstate exits (gas, food, lodging,
> etc.), finding restuarants and other items of interest while traveling (not
> necessarily at the exits...realize I will likely need to load maps on all
> units to get this info, but which ones offer the most of this detail on the
> base maps?), getting directions to these POI, depth of lakes that I might be
> boating on, etc.
>
> As mentioned, this will be my first GPS so I would like one that is easy to
> use and inexpensive. Autorouting is nice, but not critical as my next car
> will likely have a GPS factory installed in it anyway. Finding POI in a
> strange are is more important to me. Give me the address and a map and I
> can chart my own path.
>
> Craig
Hey Craig,
You might want to check compatibility with 3rd party software. I've got
an eXplorist 210, and generally enjoy using it for my various hiking
adventures, but have yet to find 3rd party software with detail maps
that are actually compatible with it.
So, I would double-check with your preferred software company to see
which unit their software works best with.
Chris
| |
| copier guy 2007-01-21, 10:33 pm |
| Craig,
Have not had any of the Magellan models you listed, but have had or
have some of the Garmins. I currently use a Legend C and a Legend Cx.
They will do all the things you want to do and more. Both can auto
route if desired.
The Legend C has enough memory to hold all the topo maps of the area
that I live, hike and play in (Shawnee National Forest). I leave it
setup for straight line navigation on foot.
The Legend Cx is the same model with expandable memory, loaded with
City Navigator for work and long road trips, or vacations. I use it in
auto route mode locked to roads.
Don't know what area you will be using your unit in but you can't go
wrong getting a unit with expandable memory. File sizes for maps keep
getting bigger with each new version. Don't depend on the base map
doing much for you. Plan on buying maps for your kind of activity.
Tom
PS. I have an older Vista (monochrome display) you can have cheap if
you want to play with a GPS before you drop big money on the one of
your dreams...
| |
| Craig 2007-01-22, 10:33 pm |
|
> PS. I have an older Vista (monochrome display) you can have cheap if
> you want to play with a GPS before you drop big money on the one of
> your dreams...
My thank you's to thegroup and especially to the post above for your advice
and offer. I did manage to snag a good deal on an almost new (only used for
a couple hours) Etrex Legend with accessories (case, 12volt power cord, pc
cable, software, etc.) I can hardly wait for it to arrive. I also
purchased a retransmitting antenna for playing with it in the car (will use
my wife as the navigator, so don't worry about me crashing while trying to
read the screen :-) ). I was really on the fence on this one...spend a bit
more to get color and SD cards or less for the B&W legend unit (or even less
for a very basic Magellan). What finally swayed me were the basemaps. For
what I plan on using it for, I may very well not need the additional maps
for quite some time, so I went with the unit that seems to offer the best
basemap. I also liked some of the extras that come bundled (fishing times
for example...I know its kind of hokey, but hey it may heighten the fun
factor a bit to see if the most productive times agree with its
predictions.) In the future I would like to purchase the lakes and fising
hot spots map, the N.A. Metroguide and the worldmap disk. (Wife and I
travel quite a bit to the Philippines where she has family and the worldmap
seems to do a decent job there...no more riding on the bus wondering which
volcano that is! :-) )
Craig
Are there any good sources for free, user created maps? I did find one for
Cozumel, Mexico but wondering if there are others? I would especially like
to have one that shows the roads and POI of Grand Cayman. It seems that
some people have made quite a hobby out of creating their own maps for the
Garmin units.
| |
| Ron Hunter 2007-01-23, 4:33 am |
| Craig wrote:
>
> My thank you's to thegroup and especially to the post above for your advice
> and offer. I did manage to snag a good deal on an almost new (only used for
> a couple hours) Etrex Legend with accessories (case, 12volt power cord, pc
> cable, software, etc.) I can hardly wait for it to arrive. I also
> purchased a retransmitting antenna for playing with it in the car (will use
> my wife as the navigator, so don't worry about me crashing while trying to
> read the screen :-) ). I was really on the fence on this one...spend a bit
> more to get color and SD cards or less for the B&W legend unit (or even less
> for a very basic Magellan). What finally swayed me were the basemaps. For
> what I plan on using it for, I may very well not need the additional maps
> for quite some time, so I went with the unit that seems to offer the best
> basemap. I also liked some of the extras that come bundled (fishing times
> for example...I know its kind of hokey, but hey it may heighten the fun
> factor a bit to see if the most productive times agree with its
> predictions.) In the future I would like to purchase the lakes and fising
> hot spots map, the N.A. Metroguide and the worldmap disk. (Wife and I
> travel quite a bit to the Philippines where she has family and the worldmap
> seems to do a decent job there...no more riding on the bus wondering which
> volcano that is! :-) )
> Craig
>
> Are there any good sources for free, user created maps? I did find one for
> Cozumel, Mexico but wondering if there are others? I would especially like
> to have one that shows the roads and POI of Grand Cayman. It seems that
> some people have made quite a hobby out of creating their own maps for the
> Garmin units.
>
>
What features are important, and what are not, depends on the use one
intends for the unit. I need the detailed maps for my purposes since
the basemaps aren't adequate for the kind of roaming I do while on
vacations. If you just intend to stay on major roads, then a basemap
may well get you around well. I visited the Niagara Falls area before
getting detailed maps and was able to find my way around quite nicely,
even with the limited routing ability of my unit using only the basemap.
I was also very surprised to find that shipping lanes were shown on
the screen while in the Gulf of Mexico on the way to Jamaica. Amazing
devices!
| |
| Keith Sheppard 2007-01-23, 4:33 am |
| >>Are there any good sources for free, user created maps? I did find one[color=darkred]
Yes, I'm one of them. My maps are all of places I've been recently on
holidays or short breaks and are therefore all European, mainly UK, but if
you're ever heading over this side of the pond raise a request here.
Keith
| |
| Craig 2007-01-24, 10:33 am |
| "I was also very surprised to find that shipping lanes were shown on
the screen while in the Gulf of Mexico on the way to Jamaica. Amazing
devices! " -- from Ron's post
> holidays or short breaks and are therefore all European, mainly UK, but if
> you're ever heading over this side of the pond raise a request here.
>
> Keith
Thank you very much for the kind offer, Keith. I'll keep it in mind.
One of these days my wife and I would like to make the trip to Europe
(she has an Aunt in Austria, and I have family in Germany, but I would
certainly love to visit the U.K. as well).
Ron, what model of GPS were you using that showed the shipping lanes?
That is a feature I would certainly enjoy. If it's from the explorist
line I just might consider a second GPS! :-)
Craig
| |
| Ron Hunter 2007-01-24, 10:33 pm |
| In-Reply-To: <1169652155.083212.185100@q2g2000cwa.googlegroups.com>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1; format=flowed
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Message-ID: < ZJOdnZBKbfJ2hCXYnZ2d
nUVZ_tTinZ2d@giganew
s.com>
Lines: 20
X-Trace: sv3-an2bBn/ YbdFq0pfvbXMK6AsQl2w
KrKZEXGxxdvUj5s6OC2I
TolwRFgb+pea2ABqUd6D
EUvWp6tm7HdN!JZZH9cC
hBwJXI+dEk+0rYdgMsOe
0nDAAT699PHMZpcGPNmR
2I7CfIlF1lptBZrLXV4J
phcEiwg==
X-Complaints-To: abuse@giganews.com
X-DMCA-Notifications: http://www.giganews.com/info/dmca.html
X-Abuse-and-DMCA-Info: Please be sure to forward a copy of ALL headers
X-Abuse-and-DMCA-Info: Otherwise we will be unable to process your complaint properly
X-Postfilter: 1.3.32
Xref: number1.nntp.dca.giganews.com alt.satellite.gps:96205 alt.satellite.gps.magellan:7751 alt.satellite.gps.garmin:12643
Craig wrote:
> "I was also very surprised to find that shipping lanes were shown on
> the screen while in the Gulf of Mexico on the way to Jamaica. Amazing
> devices! " -- from Ron's post
>
>
> Thank you very much for the kind offer, Keith. I'll keep it in mind.
> One of these days my wife and I would like to make the trip to Europe
> (she has an Aunt in Austria, and I have family in Germany, but I would
> certainly love to visit the U.K. as well).
> Ron, what model of GPS were you using that showed the shipping lanes?
> That is a feature I would certainly enjoy. If it's from the explorist
> line I just might consider a second GPS! :-)
> Craig
>
eXplorist 400.
|
|
|
|
|