|
Cellular forums Home > Archive > Garmin GPS > June 2005 > Want a GPS for the car that is portable as well
You are viewing an archived Text-only version of the thread.
To view this thread in it's original format and/or if you want to reply to
this thread please [click here]
| Author |
Want a GPS for the car that is portable as well
|
|
| Mark W 2005-06-17, 4:55 pm |
| I own a old Garmin GPS unit that is great as a portable as well as for
the car. It can run on batteries for activities such as hiking as
well as on a cigarette lighter cable for unlimited use in the car.
The problem is this is a very outdated unit so I want to update.
I will use this unit probably around 90% in the car. I do a lot of
traveling nationwide so want something very portable that I can take
in my suitcase and plug into a rental car wherever I go so of course
as well I want good nationwide maps on it.
Also, often I have someone else with me that could watch it as I'm
driving but that's not always the case so I want something that will
prompt me by voice.
The other 10% of the time though I would use it hiking. That's why
I'm interested in one that can be used on the go but none of the
models that are good for cars seem to have the option of being used
while walking. If I could find a adaptor that contains batteries that
I can plug the cigarette lighter cord into that would solve my problem
but I haven't seen these and would imagine they are heavy if they
exist.
What brand is a good brand to go with? I see mostly Garmin and
Magellan.
Is my best choice to get a good one for the car and then maybe a cheap
model for hiking? From what I see I can get a good one for the car in
the range of maybe $600 and some for hiking are only around $200.
Thanks for any help with this choice.
| |
| Alan Burnstine 2005-06-17, 4:55 pm |
| Mark W wrote:
quote:
> I own a old Garmin GPS unit that is great as a portable as well as for
> the car. It can run on batteries for activities such as hiking as
> well as on a cigarette lighter cable for unlimited use in the car.
> The problem is this is a very outdated unit so I want to update.
>
> I will use this unit probably around 90% in the car. I do a lot of
> traveling nationwide so want something very portable that I can take
> in my suitcase and plug into a rental car wherever I go so of course
> as well I want good nationwide maps on it.
>
> Also, often I have someone else with me that could watch it as I'm
> driving but that's not always the case so I want something that will
> prompt me by voice.
>
> The other 10% of the time though I would use it hiking. That's why
> I'm interested in one that can be used on the go but none of the
> models that are good for cars seem to have the option of being used
> while walking. If I could find a adaptor that contains batteries that
> I can plug the cigarette lighter cord into that would solve my problem
> but I haven't seen these and would imagine they are heavy if they
> exist.
>
> What brand is a good brand to go with? I see mostly Garmin and
> Magellan.
>
> Is my best choice to get a good one for the car and then maybe a cheap
> model for hiking? From what I see I can get a good one for the car in
> the range of maybe $600 and some for hiking are only around $200.
>
> Thanks for any help with this choice.
If Speaking is an absolute requirement, the Garmin Quest is a good choice.
It meets all your stated requirements. Probably not the best unit for
hiking, but it is adequate to the task.
If you want something a bit more all-purpose, any of the new color screen
Garmin's will provide automatic road routing and beep for upcoming turns,
but they won't speak. I find the screens quite sufficient. When there is
an upcoming turn warning, the text is quite large, and with the new screens,
very visible, so I just glance at the GPS when it beeps, and can make the
turn.
When comparing price however, be aware that the Quest comes with the City
Select software that you really need for road navigation, where it is an
extra cost item on all of the multi-purpose handhelds.
For reference, I am using a 60CS, but my statements hold true for the new
color eTrex models and the color 76 series as well.
Alan
| |
| Mark W 2005-06-17, 4:55 pm |
| Looks like a nice unit. I'll read up on it more but it does appear it
is a good all around unit and like I said I'll use it more in the car
so I prefer those features over one more catered towards hiking. I
just want to see how it compares to the other models for the road.
| |
| Steve Calvin 2005-06-17, 4:55 pm |
| Alan Burnstine wrote:
<snip>
quote:
> If Speaking is an absolute requirement, the Garmin Quest is a good choice.
> It meets all your stated requirements. Probably not the best unit for
> hiking, but it is adequate to the task.
>
> If you want something a bit more all-purpose, any of the new color screen
> Garmin's will provide automatic road routing and beep for upcoming turns,
> but they won't speak. I find the screens quite sufficient. When there is
> an upcoming turn warning, the text is quite large, and with the new screens,
> very visible, so I just glance at the GPS when it beeps, and can make the
> turn.
>
> When comparing price however, be aware that the Quest comes with the City
> Select software that you really need for road navigation, where it is an
> extra cost item on all of the multi-purpose handhelds.
>
> For reference, I am using a 60CS, but my statements hold true for the new
> color eTrex models and the color 76 series as well.
>
> Alan
>
>
I have the 76CS as well and am very pleased with it. The only
requirement stated that it doesn't satisfy is speech but as you said,
with the beeps and turning red, large print, etc I haven't had a problem
following it while on the road. I got the sandbag based holder for it
and have yet to see it move around while sitting on any dashboard.
--
Steve
Ever notice that putting the and IRS together makes "theirs"?
| |
| Tom H. 2005-06-17, 4:55 pm |
| Mark,
Regarding your remark about perhaps getting a GPS for car work and a second
one for hiking; I have a GPS V which I used for both hiking and auto travel,
but then I spotted a Geko 201 and was amazed at how small it was, so for
$115 plus about $30 for a power/data cable I bought a Geko 201. When I was
using the GPS V for hiking I seldom paid much attention to the maps, so I
don't miss the maps when I am hiking with the Geko, and the Geko is so small
I generally carry it in my shirt pocket where it can be easily accessed.
Tom
"Mark W" < markwco@RemoveNoSpam
comcast.net> wrote in message
news:ubm5b11hndojh6q
elsbkagbgqpfphobo4o@
4ax.com...
quote:
>I own a old Garmin GPS unit that is great as a portable as well as for
> the car. It can run on batteries for activities such as hiking as
> well as on a cigarette lighter cable for unlimited use in the car.
> The problem is this is a very outdated unit so I want to update.
>
> I will use this unit probably around 90% in the car. I do a lot of
> traveling nationwide so want something very portable that I can take
> in my suitcase and plug into a rental car wherever I go so of course
> as well I want good nationwide maps on it.
>
> Also, often I have someone else with me that could watch it as I'm
> driving but that's not always the case so I want something that will
> prompt me by voice.
>
> The other 10% of the time though I would use it hiking. That's why
> I'm interested in one that can be used on the go but none of the
> models that are good for cars seem to have the option of being used
> while walking. If I could find a adaptor that contains batteries that
> I can plug the cigarette lighter cord into that would solve my problem
> but I haven't seen these and would imagine they are heavy if they
> exist.
>
> What brand is a good brand to go with? I see mostly Garmin and
> Magellan.
>
> Is my best choice to get a good one for the car and then maybe a cheap
> model for hiking? From what I see I can get a good one for the car in
> the range of maybe $600 and some for hiking are only around $200.
>
> Thanks for any help with this choice.
| |
| Stan Gosnell 2005-06-18, 6:55 am |
| "Tom H." <tom_reader@att.nospam*.net> wrote in
news:OFEse.331638$cg1.293667@bgtnsc04-news.ops.worldnet.att.net:
quote:
> Mark,
> Regarding your remark about perhaps getting a GPS for car work and a
> second one for hiking; I have a GPS V which I used for both hiking and
> auto travel, but then I spotted a Geko 201 and was amazed at how small
> it was, so for $115 plus about $30 for a power/data cable I bought a
> Geko 201. When I was using the GPS V for hiking I seldom paid much
> attention to the maps, so I don't miss the maps when I am hiking with
> the Geko, and the Geko is so small I generally carry it in my shirt
> pocket where it can be easily accessed.
Connect that (or even a basic eTrex) to a PDA, either Palm or PPC,
running Mapopolis, TomTom, or such and you have everything covered for
very little money, other than the PDA. I have a Palm T3, and it gives me
voice directions, autorouting, etc, everything the Quest does, for less
than $150.
--
Regards,
Stan
"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary
safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." B. Franklin
| |
| Tom H. 2005-06-18, 4:55 pm |
| Stan,
That's a great suggestion. I will look into it the next I want to upgrade
my gps for the car.
Tom
"Stan Gosnell" <me@work.com> wrote in message
news:Xns96795356A15C
mework@204.52.135.8...
quote:
> "Tom H." <tom_reader@att.nospam*.net> wrote in
> news:OFEse.331638$cg1.293667@bgtnsc04-news.ops.worldnet.att.net:
>
>
> Connect that (or even a basic eTrex) to a PDA, either Palm or PPC,
> running Mapopolis, TomTom, or such and you have everything covered for
> very little money, other than the PDA. I have a Palm T3, and it gives me
> voice directions, autorouting, etc, everything the Quest does, for less
> than $150.
>
> --
> Regards,
>
> Stan
>
> "They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary
> safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." B. Franklin
| |
| Dirty Old Man 2005-06-19, 10:55 pm |
| I can highly recommend a Garmin IQue 3600. It does everything you are
looking for (battery life won't last long for hiking).
Alan
On Fri, 17 Jun 2005 08:09:11 -0600, Mark W
< markwco@RemoveNoSpam
comcast.net> wrote:
quote:
>I own a old Garmin GPS unit that is great as a portable as well as for
>the car. It can run on batteries for activities such as hiking as
>well as on a cigarette lighter cable for unlimited use in the car.
>The problem is this is a very outdated unit so I want to update.
>
>I will use this unit probably around 90% in the car. I do a lot of
>traveling nationwide so want something very portable that I can take
>in my suitcase and plug into a rental car wherever I go so of course
>as well I want good nationwide maps on it.
>
>Also, often I have someone else with me that could watch it as I'm
>driving but that's not always the case so I want something that will
>prompt me by voice.
>
>The other 10% of the time though I would use it hiking. That's why
>I'm interested in one that can be used on the go but none of the
>models that are good for cars seem to have the option of being used
>while walking. If I could find a adaptor that contains batteries that
>I can plug the cigarette lighter cord into that would solve my problem
>but I haven't seen these and would imagine they are heavy if they
>exist.
>
>What brand is a good brand to go with? I see mostly Garmin and
>Magellan.
>
>Is my best choice to get a good one for the car and then maybe a cheap
>model for hiking? From what I see I can get a good one for the car in
>the range of maybe $600 and some for hiking are only around $200.
>
>Thanks for any help with this choice.
| |
| David Lesher 2005-06-21, 10:56 pm |
| Mark W < markwco@RemoveNoSpam
comcast.net> writes:
quote:
>I will use this unit probably around 90% in the car. I do a lot of
>traveling nationwide so want something very portable that I can take
>in my suitcase and plug into a rental car wherever I go so of course
>as well I want good nationwide maps on it.
quote:
>Also, often I have someone else with me that could watch it as I'm
>driving but that's not always the case so I want something that will
>prompt me by voice.
My 90/10 'have it along' is towards walking, but my USAGE is more
50/50%..
I chose the 76CS over the Qwest. Here's why... the Qwest has internal
batteries; no way to replace same when they age. I gave up the speaking,
but the 76CS BLEEDLE-DEEDLES loud enough to be heard in a CRX. It has
USB as well as serial. That's a big plus for loading maps.
--
A host is a host from coast to coast.................wb8foz@nrk.com
& no one will talk to a host that's close........[v].(301) 56-LINUX
Unless the host (that isn't close).........................pob 1433
is busy, hung or dead....................................20915-1433
|
|
|
|
|